Overall, what we tend to think of as good properties of a lip balm may actually serve to irritate the skin further, not heal it. A recent project by Reviews.com analyzed 177 leading formulas to find which ones truly worked to alleviate dryness and prevent further irritation. Of these products, 151 included common irritants and allergens. Here are some of the most surprising ingredients that disqualified their front-runners:
On your lips: Tingling
The culprit? Phenol, menthol, or camphor, these chemical exfoliants are included to slough off dry skin. And while that’s usually a fine idea for much of our skin, our lips are especially sensitive. These alcohols can irritate and even burn lips — the last thing you want when you’re hoping to heal them.
On your lips: Tint or scent
Let’s get this one out of the way first: not all dyes and fragrances are bad. However, they are typically among the most common irritants, and also tend to be drying agents (even if they’re all-natural). A 2016 lawsuit against a popular lip balm brand shows that even products which claim to be 99 percent natural, organic, and gluten-free can still cause contact dermatitis. What’s more, these types of allergic reactions develop over time, so be careful rebooting an old favorite.
On the label: Vitamin E
This may come as a surprise to many readers, as we typically assume vitamin E with to be a soothing agent. I mean, it’s in almost all of our beauty products after all. Vitamin E is an antioxidant known for its anti-aging attributes, finding its way into all kinds of lotions and other moisturizers. But as a 2001 dermatological study found, 33% of participants experienced contact dermatitis (an allergic reaction) to vitamin E.
On the label: Lanolin and beeswax
Lanolin is a moisturizing alcohol which comes from wool. As with vitamin E, you’ll find it on the ingredient list of many moisturizers, despite the fact that it’s been linked to allergic reactions in some people.
Beeswax is a very common moisturizer found in many popular lip balms and other types of products. It’s incredibly effective in lip balm, which is why so many people swear by it. Beeswax does, however, usually contain propolis, which has been known to irritate lips.
So while you don’t need to go around throwing away your favorite lip balms, this is something to note if you’re struggling to find a solution that doesn’t irritate your lips.
So while you don’t need to go around throwing away your favorite lip balms, this is something to note if you’re struggling to find a solution that doesn’t irritate your lips.
Ultimately, the best lip balm for you will be a matter of combination, personal preference, and convenience. Keep an eye out for common irritants and allergens, particularly if you’re naturally prone to reactions. To see which balms worked best and to read more about finding the best one for you, check out the full article here: https://www.reviews.com/lip-balm/
I’ve always thought, that if it doesn’t cost much, has flavors like Tootsie Roll or Dr. Pepper, decorated with princesses, or looks like a lipstick…it’s probably not a good moisturizing and helpful balm for my lips. Yes, the others are fun to have, but in the dry winter months, it’s best to stick to the good ones! ~ Johanna