Hit or Miss? Best and Worst Disney Film Sequels Revealed!

disney film sequels - hocus pocus 2

Online discount toy retailer Bargain Max has looked into the best and worst Disney film sequels following the latest news of Hocus Pocus 2 coming to Disney+ in 2022!

Hocus Pocus originally came out on 29 October 1993 and since then, there has been no follow-up sequel to the iconic Halloween-themed blockbuster. Fans of the film have been calling out for a sequel since its first launch 28 years ago. 

According to fans on Reddit, “Hocus Pocus is a movie that I rewatch over and over again every single year around Halloween time and it never gets old. It’s one of the most rewatchable movies ever and the ultimate Halloween time movie. And that makes it a timeless classic in my eyes.”

Whilst others are less than impressed, questioning the ability of Witches being able to come back from ‘dust’: “So how do they come back from dust? Bonus points if Mary upgrades to a cordless Dyson.”

Whilst another added:

“Just hoping they do something completely different from the sequel book. There were some…interesting choices made there.”

Finally, some feel social media could help bring them back:

“Some viral TikTok video gets millions of kids to do the forbidden Salem dance and song that brings them back.”

The original Hocus Pocus film has an IMDb rating of 6.9/10, can Hocus Pocus 2 top this rating? With the hype for a sequel there, how it fairs to the original is yet to be seen, will it be a hit or a miss?

Looking into other popular film sequels, Bargain Max has rounded up the top 20 animated and non-animated sequels, based on their IMDb film rating (ordered highest to lowest) and thoughts from followers on social media through a nationwide poll. 

disney film sequels

Top animated disney film sequels: 

#1 – Toy Story 2 – there are so many Toy Stories, but what’s not to like about Toy Story 2 (1999)? 7.9/10 – IMDb

Original – Toy Story (1995) – 8.3/10 – IMDb (4.8% decrease in score).

#2 – Finding Dory (2016) – 7.3/10 – IMDb

– Original – Finding Nemo (2003) – 8.1/10  – IMDb (9.9% decrease in score).

#3- Frozen II (2019) – 6.8/10 – IMDb

– Original – Frozen (2013) – 7.4/10 – IMDb (8.1% decrease in score).


#4 – Cinderella 2: Dreams Come True (2001) – there was also a third! 5/10 – IMDb

– Original – Cinderella (1950) – 7.3/10 – IMDb (31.5% decrease in score).

#5- Aladdin (yes! – The Return of Jafar!) (1994) – 5.9/10 – IMDb

– Original – Aladdin (1992) – 8/10 – IMDb (26.2% decrease in score).

#6 – Lady and the Tramp II: Scamp’s Adventure (2001) 5.9/10 – IMDb

– Original – Lady and the Tramp (1955) – 7.3/10 – IMDb (19.2% decrease in score).

#7 – Mulan II (2004) – 5.7/10 – IMDb

– Original – Mulan (1998) – 7.6/10 – IMDb (25% decrease in score).

#8 – Tarzan 2: The Legend Begins (2005) –  5.6/10 – IMDb

– Original – Tarzan (1999) – 7.3/10 – IMDb (24.7% decrease in score).


#9 – The Little Mermaid II: Return to the Sea (2000) – 5.6/10 – IMDb

– Original – The Little Mermaid (1989) – 7.6/10 – IMDb (26.3% decrease in score).


#10 – The Jungle Book 2 (2003)  5.4/10 – IMDb

– Original – The Jungle Book (1967) – 7.6/10 – IMDb (28.9% decrease in score).

None animated sequels: 

#11 – Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest (2006) – 8/10 – IMDb
Original – Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (2003) 8/10 – IMDb (No change in score)

#12 – Return to Oz – The Wizard of Oz (2007) – 8/10 – IMDb
Original – The Wizard of Oz (1939) – 8/10 – IMDb (No change in score).

#13 – Back to the Future Part III (1989) – 7.8/10 – IMDb
– Original – Back to the Future (1985) – 8.5/10 – IMDb (5% decrease in score).

#14 – Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (2017) – 7.6/10 – IMDb
– Original – Guardians of the Galaxy (2014) – 8/10 – IMDb (5.26% increase in score).

#15 – Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992) – 6.8/10 – IMDb
Original – Home Alone (1990) – 7.6/10 – IMDb (10.5% decrease in score).

#16 – Mary Poppins Returns (2018) 6.7/10 – IMDb
Original – Mary Poppins (1964) – 7.8/10 – IMDb (14.10% decrease in score).

#17 – The Lost World: Jurassic Park (1997) 6.6/10 – IMDb
Original – Jurassic Park (1993) – 8.1/10 – IMDb (18.5% decrease in score).

#18 – High School Musical 2 (2007) 5.1/10 – IMDb
Original – High School Musical (2005) – 5.5/10 – IMDb (7.2% decrease in score).

#19 – Son Of The Mask 2 (2005) 2.2/10 – IMDb
Original – The Mask (1994) – 6.9/10 – IMDb (68.11% decrease in score).

#20 – George of The Jungle 2 (2003) 3.4/10 – IMDb
– Original – George of The Jungle (1997) – 5.5/10 – IMDb (38.18% decrease in score).


Toy Story 2 and Pirates of The Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest are amongst the top rated sequels for both animated and non animated movies. Whilst some of the worst by vote are The Jungle Book 2 and George of The Jungle 2.

The worst sequel is Son of The Mask 2 with a 68.11% decrease in rating compared to the original.

Toy expert & Movie Buff Daniel McKay of Bargain Max commented: 

“We don’t know about you, but Hocus Pocus is still an absolute classic and we are excited for the second one!

28 years we have been waiting, and the news of the sequel has caused quite the debate with some fans questioning the ability of a Witch to bounce back from being turned to dust as the story tells in the original!

We also asked our followers their favourite sequels they most love and the most popular sequels commented were Toy Story 2 and Frozen 2.

So do you prefer animated sequels or something a little more real? Either way, Hocus Pocus 2 should be a treat for all and hopefully not a trick!

Avatar photo
About Guest Writer 4568 Articles
Thanks for reading this guest article. If you would like to guest post for us then see our guidelines here. Thanks :)