New research reveals the rise of the AI “bestie” and the very human reasons we’re not ready to swipe left on real friendship.
Move over group chat, there’s a new friend in town, and it never leaves you on read. New research from greeting card marketplace thortful reveals that 1 in 6 UK adults (16.8%) have turned to AI over an actual friend for advice, comfort or a second opinion – and 12.8% have gone as far as calling their chatbot a genuine long-term companion.
But don’t panic yet, robots are not stealing our mates: the same research shows humans are still very much winning. A comfortable 68.3% of Brits have never chosen AI over a person for advice or support, and even among the AI-curious, almost half (46.9%) admit they still prefer their own thinking to whatever the chatbot suggests. Turns out we like having a digital sounding board – one we get to switch on/off at will.
So, is turning to AI instead of the group chat a red flag? Not necessarily, says behaviour specialist Sim Shamu – it all comes down to the role it plays:
“I don’t think turning to AI before another person is automatically a cause for concern. For me, the important thing is what the tool is doing for you. Used like that, it can act almost like rehearsal – helping someone organise their thoughts, understand a concept and then going back into the real interaction better prepared,” he comments. “Instead, we should be asking whether the tool is helping us participate more effectively in our relationships or gradually replacing parts of those relationships.”
Key findings
- Over half of us (54.3%) have used AI for at least one or more these reasons – from writing work emails to health questions to asking it what to say during an argument (5.8% of us have genuinely outsourced the last word in a row to a chatbot).
- Friends are the most “replaced” relationship – more than parents (8.2), partners (7.2%), or even the boss (7.2%). Yes, we’ll second guess our boss before we would a lawyer (4.0%) or a doctor (5.8%) – but it’s our mates who get swapped out most.
- Companionship has a gender twist. Men are notably more likely to call their AI a genuine long-term companion (16.4% vs 9.7% of women) – while women are twice as likely to rate the AI’s actual advice as genuinely good logic (25.3% vs 12.5% of men). Women want the AI to be right (or tell them they are); men want it to stick around.
- Edinburgh, Southampton and Manchester are UK’s most AI-attached cities, each with around 1 in 5 residents describing their chatbot as a long-term companion.
- The generation gap looks more like a U than a slope. Both the youngest adults (18-24) and the over-55s are the most likely to say they still prefer their own output to AI’s – it’s the 25-54s, busy juggling wok, family and everything in between, who’ve leaned into AI the hardest.
So…is AI stealing our friends?
Not really but it is clearly auditioning for a supporting role. Researchers worldwide have flagged real long-term questions about what happens when always-available, endlessly patient AI starts filling gaps that used to belong to people. This research suggests that shift is already happening in the UK, in a small but very real way.
The good news? The numbers say we’re not handing over the keys just yet. We’re delegating the small stuff – the awkward text, the “how do I phrase this” panic, the 11pm existential spiral – while keeping our actual friendships for, well, being actual friends. AI’s earned itself a seat at the table, it just hasn’t been invited to the wedding.
So, before we hand AI a permanent seat at the table, Shamu says it is worth asking what we are actually using it for:
“The question is what role AI is serving in the moment? Rehearsal, reassurance, information, avoidance, or decision-making – because those uses are likely to have very different consequences. Your survey found both substantial continued preference for people’s own judgement and a smaller group reporting AI as a longer-term companion, so there may be several different patterns sitting underneath the headline figures.”
And is it good for us?
There is also a very understandable behavioural reason people may choose AI over a difficult conversation. If speaking to somebody feels embarrassing, uncertain or likely to lead to conflict, avoiding that conversation can bring immediate relief. Behaviourally, that relief can reinforce the avoidance, even when having the conversation might be much more beneficial in the longer term. If AI repeatedly becomes the easier route out of uncomfortable interaction, there is a risk that the person gets less practice with the very interpersonal skills they need to become fluent in.
For me, the habit becomes worth examining when it starts affecting quality of life – when somebody feels less able to have a conversation, make a decision, tolerate uncertainty or maintain a relationship without first relying on AI. I don’t think though that we need to be avoiding AI. Instead, we should be asking whether the tool is helping us participate more effectively in our relationships, or gradually replacing parts of those relationships.
If you’re the type to freeze up staring at a blank card? You’re not alone – over 1 in 9 Brits (11.4%) have turned to AI for help finding the right words to write in a card. If “Happy Birthday, hope you have a great one!” is the best you’ve got, here is how thortful can help you say it better: https://www.thortful.com/blog/category/what-to-write/
Photo by Markus Winkler: https://www.pexels.com/photo/chatgpt-spelled-with-wooden-letter-tiles-on-table-30869075/
Leave a Reply